The biggest
thing that makes (together) instantly weaker than anything The Antlers have
ever produced is the fact that their albums always seem like a whole piece of
work, carefully constructed and put together in just the right way. (together)
does not share that property, and as a result, it feels a bit too stitched together
to really stand out.
'Tongue Tied' is
undoubtedly the highlight of the EP, being the only genuinely new track on the
album. It has a similar tone to that of Burst Apart while exchanging the subtle
drum beat for an electronic drum sample. The track could have appeared on Burst
Apart and fit in well. The re-workings of tracks such as 'French Exit' and 'I
Don't Want Love' work well to display the diversity of the band and the
different directions that Burst Apart could have gone in. The latter is a
stripped down version of the song that showcases Peter Silberman's haunting
vocal work as best as any song they've done before.
Their cover of 'VCR' by The xx is an admirable effort, but The xx are so good at playing their
material that I always feel like covers of their music can never do the tracks justice (case in point; Birdy). With a hazy atmosphere and synth-infused bleeps throughout, the track doesn't reflect the minimalist feel of the original, but it maintains
the soothing, naive feel of it.
The Antlers - VCR (The xx Cover) by The 405
The EP has three
collaborations on it, with Nicole Atkins, Bear in Heaven and Neon Indian.
They're all re-workings of previous work from Burst Apart. The one that stands
out the most is their collaboration with Bear in Heaven, where they have created
a sprawling, 18-minute version of 'Parenthesis'. It sees the two bands creating a
exhaustive jam session which they just so happened to get on tape. The track
lacks focus and direction, but it's nice to see what the two long-time tour
buddies can do when left to their own devices.
Nicole Atkins'
lower voice contracts well with Silberman's on 'Hounds', creating a soothing,
moving piece that stands up against the original version well. When vocalising
together, their voices don't create the most ear-pleasing vocal harmonies, but
when they're turn taking the sound works well. Since the source material is so
strong it works well together.
As a whole,
(together) isn't necessarily a bad collection of songs. It just seems to lack
the focus, polish or direction that The Antlers show by the bucket load in
their previous albums. (together) seems like a hard-sell to anyone who hasn't
already exhausted their previous discography first. Hardcore Antlers
fans will no-doubt find a lot to enjoy, though. So there's that.
6/10
Awesome blog man! Just found out amazing things throughout your posts. Funny how it looks quite like a blog I have with a friend, http://ventiladores.wordpress.com , it is in portuguese since i'm brazillian, but you might something of your interest. c ya.
ReplyDelete